The line was hundreds deep by 5 a.m., a full four hours before Tucson鈥檚 only charity dental event began.
No overnight camping was allowed but some did it anyway. Ages ranged from infants to seniors, but those in line had one thing in common 鈥 none felt they could afford dental care. There were people in their 30s missing teeth, seniors with gum disease, and children with unfilled cavities.
Tempers flared when a volunteer, accompanied by security guards, told those at the back of the line they would not be able to get help this time.
Nearly one-quarter of Tucson-area residents lives in poverty, and it shows in their teeth. Poor oral health sends people of all ages to the emergency room with infected abscesses, and people without dental care are vulnerable to heart and kidney disease, diabetes, high blood pressure and even premature death.
People are also reading…
The problem is a common one here. Tucson is among the six largest 50 cities in the country that does not fluoridate its water or have enough naturally occurring fluoride to prevent cavities, according to a federal analysis. Medicare, which is government insurance for seniors, does not include dental coverage, and fewer than 1 percent of the health plans sold through the Affordable Care Act鈥檚 federal marketplaces include adult dental care, the national Children鈥檚 Dental Health Project says.
In 2008, the Arizona Legislature eliminated preventative dental services to Arizona Medicaid enrollees with intellectual and developmental disabilities, and to seniors who were both eligible for Medicaid and clients of its Arizona Long Term Care Services program.
Arizona鈥檚 Medicaid program, a government health insurance program for low-income people, has never offered comprehensive dental coverage to adults, though it did once cover emergency dental and medically necessary dentures for adults 21 and older.
But because of state budget slashing, Medicaid in Arizona, which is called the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System (AHCCCS), has not provided emergency dental coverage or dentures to adult enrollees older than 21 since Oct. 1, 2010.
The exception is medical and surgical dental services that could be considered a 鈥減hysician service,鈥 for a condition such as a fractured jaw or infection.
The AHCCCS cuts appear to have resulted in a spike in emergency-room visits.
Emergency-room treat-and-release visits for oral health problems in the state jumped by 29 percent between 2009 and 2011, data from the Arizona Department of Health Services shows. The number of emergency room cases where oral health was the primary or secondary reason for inpatient admission jumped by 37 percent in that same time period, the Arizona-based Adult Benefit Coalition for Dental Care says.
A lack of coverage for low-income pregnant women is particularly concerning to health advocates because nearly one quarter of Arizonans, including the mothers of more than half the babies born here last year, get their health-care from AHCCCS. Gum disease can be passed to an unborn child, causing prematurity and illness.
Education and policy changes could improve oral health in Arizonans. Among the ideas: including adult dental care in Arizona鈥檚 Medicaid program coverage, allowing a new type of mid-level provider called a dental therapist to ease a provider shortage, fluoridating tap water and cleaning the teeth of patients in hospital intensive care units 鈥 a measure that could reduce infections and deaths among critically ill patients, since bacteria can grow on breathing tubes, leading to ventilator-associated pneumonia.
Not early enough
October鈥檚 HopeFest, held at Kino Stadium in Tucson, could help only 600 of the thousands of people who sought free dental care. Wristbands were given on a first-come first-serve basis and many left disappointed. Yolanda Hernandez left holding the hand of her son, 27-year-old Diego Santiago, who has Down syndrome. They arrived more than two hours before the event began, but that wasn鈥檛 early enough.
Santiago, who clutched a balloon as his mother asked for help, has health insurance through Medicaid. But under AHCCCS, he does not qualify for dental benefits because he is older than 21, despite the fact he has a disability.
Nine-year-old Brionna Baker sobbed as she stood in line with her aunt, grandmother and her 10-year-old neighbor and friend, Madison Bricker. Brionna鈥檚 family earns too much to qualify for AHCCCS, but not enough to pay for dental care.
The family arrived at HopeFest at 2 a.m. and by 8:30 a.m. Brionna was hungry and upset at the arguing around her as officials started turning people away.
Nearly one quarter of Arizona children ages 1 through 17 has at least one oral health problem such as toothaches, cavities, broken teeth and bleeding gums, the Oregon-based Data Resource Center for Child & Adolescent Health says. The survey鈥檚 state-by-state ranking on oral health problems in children places Arizona toward the bottom of the 50 states and the District of Columbia, ahead of only New Mexico and Mississippi.
鈥淐overing kids is relatively inexpensive and easy to do,鈥 said Dr. Daniel Derksen, a professor at the University of Arizona鈥檚 Mel and Enid Zuckerman College of Public Health and director of its Center for Rural Health. 鈥淏ut it鈥檚 a challenge to really make sure those who are most vulnerable are getting preventive services.鈥
While events like HopeFest in Tucson are helpful, dental care needs to be accessible, available and affordable every day, Derksen said. But the opposite is happening: Arizona has eliminated enrollment in KidsCare, a federal health insurance program for children whose parents earn slightly more than the Medicaid cutoff. That program included dental coverage.
Also, the state had higher-than-average standalone dental premiums for children in the U.S. during the 2013-14 enrollment season, a survey by the national Children鈥檚 Dental Health Project says. 鈥淲e don鈥檛 need to settle for kids losing their teeth before they start grade school and high school. It鈥檚 unconscionable,鈥 Derksen said. 鈥淚t is all within our control. This is affecting real people and it鈥檚 an unacceptable situation.鈥
The federal Affordable Care Act was supposed to help, but it has a loophole where families aren鈥檛 penalized if they don鈥檛 get pediatric dental coverage. Only 34 percent of health plans sold in federal marketplaces included pediatric dental coverage, the national Children鈥檚 Dental Health Project says 鈥 and that鈥檚 even though the law defines children鈥檚 dental care and designated pediatric dental care among 10 鈥渆ssential benefits.鈥
鈥淭his came about inadvertently,鈥 said Dr. Paul Reggiardo, immediate past chair of the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry鈥檚 Council on Dental Benefit Programs. 鈥淛ust because of some very fine tuning of the wording it wasn鈥檛 written as clearly as it should have been.鈥
For now, pediatric dental coverage purchased through the Affordable Care Act is an optional product for most families 鈥 and that鈥檚 not likely to change soon, Reggiardo said.
鈥淣o one on either side of the aisle is going to want to touch the modification of the Affordable Care Act 鈥 once you open it up, it is opened up to any kind of modification,鈥 he said. 鈥淔rom a realistic point of view, the earliest would be after 2016 and it might occur after the next presidential election. But eventually there will be modification.鈥
States do have the option of making pediatric dental coverage mandatory, and a few have taken that step. But not enough, Reggiardo said.
鈥淯ntil we have 100 percent coverage,鈥 he said, 鈥渨e can鈥檛 be satisfied.鈥
STARTING YOUNG
Ask any dental hygienist who works on a mobile health unit and he or she will tell you the same thing 鈥 plenty of preschoolers in Arizona have never used a toothbrush.
鈥淲e have them put the toothbrush in their mouth and some of them have never seen it before. They don鈥檛 know what to do with it,鈥 said Joyce Flieger, a dental hygienist who directs the First Smiles program for preschoolers in Cochise County.
鈥淪ome of them have toothbrushes at home but have never received instructions on holding it,鈥 Flieger said. 鈥淪ome can get their four front teeth but don鈥檛 brush the back ones. That鈥檚 why parents need to help brush their children鈥檚 teeth.鈥
Then there are the kids who know about toothbrushes but they don鈥檛 have their own, said Megan Miks, manager of the community oral health department at Chandler Regional Medical Center. They share with other family members, potentially passing around bacteria.
The American Dental Association strongly recommends that parents take children to their first dental visit before age 1. But most Arizona parents don鈥檛 do that, the local association says.
Even though AHCCCS covers pediatric dental care, not all providers accept it. No pediatric dentists in Cochise County take AHCCCS, for example, Flieger said.
Another reason is parental mindset. Parents who lack dental coverage often see dental care as something that is expensive and to be avoided unless there鈥檚 a major problem like a toothache.
In states where parents have oral health benefits under Medicaid, more do take their kids to the dentist. California lost its Medicaid dental benefits for adults in 2009, and fewer parents brought their kids to the dentist, the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry鈥檚 Reggiardo said. Adult benefits in that state were partially restored this year.
A recent Gallup Survey said 59 percent of Arizonans reported visiting the dentist in the last year, which was one of the worst rates in the U.S. For the third year in a row, Connecticut topped the poll. Seventy-five percent of its residents said they had visited a dentist in the last 12 months.
If kids could get to the age of 5 with healthy teeth, Flieger said, it would be a huge step in improving overall oral health. She鈥檇 like to see more dental hygienists in school districts 鈥 something the Tucson Unified School District already does, and she鈥檇 like to see more communities fluoridating their water to optimal levels. 鈥淚t鈥檚 all about changing behaviors with the young,鈥 she said.
Children living in Arizona鈥檚 Native American communities have a particularly serious problem, with decay rates that are about 400 percent higher than other children. Dental coalitions have formed in eight tribal communities in Arizona to address the problem.
Among other things, advocates want to get health insurance, including dental coverage, for more American Indian children. Many are eligible, but not enrolled.
鈥淜ids are losing teeth because of a lack of access to oral health services,鈥 said Derksen, of the UA. 鈥淥nce you lose your permanent teeth, you are stuck with that for life.鈥
He stresses that the health consequences of tooth abscesses and bacterial infections due to tooth decay can be dire. In one well-publicized case in 2007, a 12-year-old Maryland boy died from complications of a tooth abscess, when bacteria from the infection spread from his jaw to his brain.
NEW LAWS COULD HELP
Every Wednesday for the past few weeks, an oral health task force from across the state has gathered at the Arizona Capitol to draft dental legislation.
An initial proposal included strategies to add dental providers in rural areas, add teledentistry, add preventive dental benefits for adults to AHCCCS and encourage fluoridated water statewide.
The group is now working to narrow its priorities. One of the most popular measures is cleaning up language in Arizona鈥檚 Dental Practice Act that stipulates dentists must first give an exam to any child who receives cavity-preventing sealants from a dental hygienist. Some members want to remove the stipulation so more children can get sealants.
Another way to create more access to oral health care in Arizona would be allowing a midlevel provider called a dental therapist, which are used in three states and more than 50 countries.
Akin to nurse practitioners and physician assistants, dental therapists can fill cavities, do extractions and stainless-steel crowns that could help ease the shortage of dentists in rural areas and American Indian reservations. Alaska had a similar problem on its tribal land, which is why the state recently agreed to license dental therapists.
However, dental therapists have proven a political and controversial issue in the dental profession and the Arizona task force as of last week was not planning to take on advocating to add them to the workforce. Critics from The American Dental Association and the Alaskan Dental Society took court action in an attempt to block dental therapists from going to work on tribal land in Alaska in 2005, but the lawsuit failed.
Advocates maintain dental therapists could help significantly improve oral health in the U.S. because in states where they are practicing, they primarily treat children, low-income adults, Native Americans and those who would not otherwise have access to dental care.
providing hope
Tucson鈥檚 annual HopeFest offers free medical and dental care as well as free showers, groceries and haircuts. But the dental component is the biggest part of the event, said the event鈥檚 dental director, Dr. Dean Hauseman, a Tucson endodontist who has worked at HopeFest for 17 of the event鈥檚 22 years.
鈥淭his is a drop in the bucket,鈥 Hauseman said as he coordinated the transport of some patients. 鈥淭here is so much need and so little we can do.鈥
Thirty-five-year-old Cami Southard felt like she鈥檇 won the lottery when she found out she鈥檇 be getting dental care at HopeFest. Southard recently got out of jail, is now living at a shelter, and wants to be a substance abuse counselor.
Her own abuse of crystal methamphetamine affected her teeth, said Southard, who said she is now sober. She had two teeth pulled while in jail. Having broken and missing teeth is causing her pain, and also is affecting her self-esteem, she said. She鈥檚 already been to the hospital for a severe toothache. Antibiotics cleared up the infection, but the pain did not go away.
Tooth extractions were common at HopeFest this year. Though the final numbers weren鈥檛 yet in, Hauseman said one clinic saw 68 patients of all ages who needed a total of nearly 400 teeth extracted. Many of those patients would rather be toothless than be in the pain that their teeth are causing, he said.
Forty-nine-year-old Dominica Hawkins left HopeFest in tears. She was turned away after waiting because she didn鈥檛 have a wristband. She said she was in the bathroom when they handed them out. Hawkins, who is missing all of her lower teeth and most of her upper ones, has health insurance through her husband but it doesn鈥檛 cover dental care. She said her teeth fell out due to medical problems.
鈥淪ocially, I鈥檓 looked at as a crack addict,鈥 she said. 鈥淚 can鈥檛 find any office job. I鈥檓 a people person and I love to smile, but it鈥檚 embarrassing. I鈥檓 disgusted with myself.鈥
Fifty-year-old Ann Dunbar knows that feeling. She鈥檇 made her own fake tooth from an acrylic fingernail when she first turned up at HopeFest. She went four years in a row and two years ago got a cost-free set of dentures.
Free HopeFest dentures are considered the 鈥済old ticket,鈥 since only 45 to 50 sets are available. A full set normally costs about $3,000 to $3,500.
鈥淵ou can鈥檛 cut hair if you have a hole in your face,鈥 said Dunbar, who is a hairstylist. 鈥淚 needed a lot of work. I鈥檇 had quotes of $25,000 to fix my teeth and I didn鈥檛 have that.鈥
She now wonders whether the heart attack she suffered at the age of 36 was related to the tooth decay that began in her 20s. There was plaque in her heart and on her teeth, she said.
Grateful for the help she received, Dunbar volunteered at last weekend鈥檚 HopeFest. She said people seem to feel at ease talking to her because she understands.
鈥淭here is a lot of fear involved 鈥 fear of pain and cost,鈥 Dunbar said. 鈥淚t was very hard for me to take that next step. By the time you go to HopeFest, you are pretty desperate.鈥
Dunbar now holds down two jobs 鈥 one in retail for a beauty supplier and one as a hairstylist.
鈥淒entures have changed everything for me,鈥 she said.
