Starting at 5:45 a.m. on Election Day in November 2016, I circumnavigated Tucson, driving about 120 miles to interview voters.
I came away realizing I, already a solidly anti-Trump columnist, had been out of touch. In more than two dozen voter interviews, I spoke with many Trump supporters of different backgrounds and realized there was logic to their decision: They wanted an abrupt change, the kind that Trump was offering, and rejected the status quo sameness of voting for another Clinton.
US President Donald Trump, in a farewell address released on Tuesday, urged prayers for the new administration of President-elect Joe Biden but declined to acknowledge his Democratic successor by name.
In 2016, many anti-Trump Americans like me discovered there was a big, Trump-inclined country out there we had overlooked. Republican activists have often referred to it as “Real America” and its residents as “Real Americans.”
Now, on Joe Biden and Kamala Harris’ inauguration day, it’s the Trump supporters’ turn to accept there is another “real America” out there. Avid Trumpists like Arizona GOP Chair Kelli Ward want to portray Biden supporters as radicals or globalists or elitists, but come on — there aren’t 81 million Americans fitting all of those categories put together.
People are also reading…
We are also real, everyday Americans from real America.
Acceptance of this fact isn’t just a favor one columnist is asking for — it’s a recognition that is essential to reconciliation in America after Trump’s presidency and especially after Jan. 6. Without it, we will have a hard time going forward together as we must.
I first noticed the phrase “real America” in 2008. Sarah Palin, then John McCain’s running mate, visited Greensboro, N.C., in October that year. She said it at a rally there:
“We believe that the best of America is in these small towns that we get to visit, and in these wonderful little pockets of what I call the real America, being here with all of you hard working, very patriotic, very pro-America areas of this great nation.”
We all know what she was talking about. Sometimes pundits and politicians refer to it as “the heartland,” a phrase I find extremely grating. Journalists seek out its wisdom at greasy spoon diners. The idea is that these are pickup-driving, church-going, physical-laboring people who are the bedrock of the country.
It’s stereotyping, for sure. And it’s an arrogant conceit to suggest that these people are more “real” or important than residents of other parts of the country, like Tucson, or people who have different choices of vehicle, faith or job.
It’s also politically ignorant: The county where Palin was speaking voted for Obama that year and in 2012, as well as Clinton in 2016 and Biden last year. “Real America,” if we put any stock in Palin’s categorization, supports Democrats as well as Republicans.
That obvious reality — that there isn’t a more and less “American” part of the United States — didn’t stop Trump from driving home the idea throughout his presidency that only Trump-supporting America was the real thing, and no one else really belongs.
After winning thanks to the magic of the Electoral College, Trump spent his presidency catering strictly to his supporters, lashing out against his opponents and painting them as a hated other.
Via Twitter, Trump said this in July 2019 about four American members of Congress:
“So interesting to see ‘Progressive’ Democrat Congresswomen, who originally came from countries whose governments are a complete and total catastrophe, the worst, most corrupt and inept anywhere in the world (if they even have a functioning government at all), now loudly and viciously telling the people of the United States, the greatest and most powerful Nation on earth, how our government is to be run. Why don’t they go back and help fix the totally broken and crime infested places from which they came.”
Three of the four people he was referring to were born in the United States — only one, Rep. Ilhan Omar, was born overseas. But being Democrats, being from cities, being brown-skinned, or having names that aren’t traditionally Anglo, made them essentially foreign to Trump.
This might not matter much if it didn’t justify his supporters’ efforts to throw out the votes of people they consider insufficiently American, and to violently overturn the election.
“We’re the people — this is our house” was one of the exhortations shouted repeatedly in the crowd outside the U.S. Capitol before pro-Trump protesters stormed it. Their sense of themselves as real Americans convinced them the rest of us real Americans, the 81 million who voted for Biden, couldn’t possibly exist.
But we do. For further evidence, look to Georgia. Two months after the Nov. 3 presidential election Biden narrowly won there, Georgia held essentially a re-run in its runoff election for U.S. Senate. The Democrats did even better than Biden had, and the Republican candidates conceded without complaint about the electoral process.
This other real America exists, in even greater numbers than the one Trump has uplifted. And it deserves the same respect and recognition.
Photos: Presidential campaign visits in Tucson since 1960
Kennedy-Johnson presidential campaign in 1960

Sen. John F. Kennedy stepped off his DC-3 campaign plane and was greeted by about 150 people and given a sombrero and "an undersized cowboy hat," according to the Tucson Citizen, at Tucson Municipal Airport in April 1960, during an appearance in Tucson, Ariz.
John F. Kennedy

Riding from airport with John F. Kennedy during the Democratic Presidential candidate's 1960 visit to Tucson were City Democratic Chairman David Ginsburg, County Vice Chairman Joe Huerta, Mayor Don Hummel and County Democratic Chairman Frank Minarik. Photo from "Jack Sheaffer's Tucson 1945-1965."
Presidential campaigns in Tucson: Barry Goldwater

Arizona Sen. Barry Goldwater arriving at the Pioneer Hotel in downtown Tucson on June 24, 1964, during his campaign for president. Goldwater was running for against incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson. Note Pima Savings Building in the background. It's now a City of Tucson building. At the base of the building is Little Cafe Poca Cosa.
Presidential campaigns in Tucson: Barry Goldwater

Arizona's Favorite Son, Republican Sen. Barry Goldwater, at the podium for "Breakfast with Barry" with 1,200 guests at the Pioneer Hotel in downtown Tucson on June 24, 1964. Goldwater was running for president against incumbent Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson. It was a pricey $5-a-plate affair. Most people dressed in short sleeves on the heals of a 103-degree scorcher the day prior. Goldwater spoke prophetically about the war in Vietnam. "I can't help feeling there will be disaster in Vietnam unless something is done soon," he said. Goldwater visited Nogales afterward – a rare stop for presidential candidates.
Kennedy-Johnson presidential campaign in 1960

Senator Lyndon Johnson, waving his cowboy hat to the crowd, during a campaign stop for the Kennedy-Johnson presidential campaign at Tucson Municipal Airport on Sept. 15, 1960. At left, former Arizona Gov. Ernest McFarland, Arizona Sen. Carl Hayden. Congressman Stewart Udall, destined to be Secretary of the Interior in the Kennedy administration, is to the right of Johnson.
Kennedy-Johnson presidential campaign in 1960

Lyndon B. Johnson reaches for a hand during a campaign stop at the University of Arizona in Tucson on Sept. 15, 1960. It was a "folksy visit," according to the Tucson Citizen, "a shirt-sleeved, handshaking and child-hugging rush through Tucson." Johnson was John F. Kennedy's running mate in the 1960 presidential election.
Richard M. Nixon

While Mrs. Richard A. Ports watches, Richard M. Nixon signs an autograph for an unidentified student (left) after the dedication of a library to the late Richard A. Ports at the Alpha Tau Omega house, 1451 N. Warren Ave, Tucson, in 1965.
Richard Nixon

Richard Nixon wishes Congressional Republican hopeful Mac Matheson lots of luck in his campaign before leaving Tucson Airport last night after a brief ranch vacation in 1961.
George Wallace

Alabama Gov George Wallace addresses an audience at the University of ӰAV on January 9, 1964. Months before he had already announced his intention to be the presidential nominee for the Democratic Party in the 1964 elections. A year before, Wallace famously declared during his oath of office as governor,"...segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever." During his speech at the UA he said the Civil Rights Bill would blot out personal liberty and establish total federal control over individual lives. P
George Wallace

Alabama Gov George Wallace addresses an audience at the University of ӰAV on January 9, 1964. Months before he had already announced his intention to be the presidential nominee for the Democratic Party in the 1964 elections.
Hubert H. Humphrey

Sen. Hubert H. Humphrey, the 1964 Democratic nominee for vice president, addresses a reported 7,000 people during an outdoor rally at the Tucson Sports Center on November 1, 1964.
Hubert H. Humphrey

Sen. Hubert H. Humphrey, lower right, the 1964 Democratic nominee for vice president, wades through supporters after addressing a reported 7,000 spectators during an outdoor rally at the Tucson Sports Center on November 1, 1964.
Presidential campaigns in Tucson: George McGovern

Sen. George McGovern, D-S.D., talks with a group during a "rap session" with a mixed-minority group of about 100 at the Welfare Rights Organization headquarters on S. 4th Ave. in Tucson on Jan. 10, 1972. McGovern was campaigning for the party's nomination as President of the United States.
Mo Udall

Congressman Morris K. "Mo" Udall relaxes on a bus in between campaign stops in 1980 in Tucson. Mo Udall, longtime U.S. Representative from Southern Arizona, and brother Stewart were deeply respected for their government service. Mo was defeated by Jimmy Carter in the 1972 Democratic Presidential primary. He decided against another run for President in 1984 after being diagnosed with Parkinson's disease.
Ronald and Nancy Reagan

Former California Governor Ronald Reagan, center, and his wife, Nancy Reagan, meet with someone during a visit to Flowing Wells High School on October 26, 1979. The future president was a featured speaker at the school's annual Bellamy Award Day.
Bill Clinton

Pres. Bill Clinton didn't campaign in Tucson, but he is known for his lunch stop, and the lunch plate named after him, at Mi Nidito in South Tucson in 1999..
George W. Bush

Texas Governor and Republican presidential candidate George W. Bush Jr., greeted by Ray Castillo, Tucson Mayor Bob Walkup, Rick Grinnell, and auto dealer Jim Click at the Executive terminal of Tucson International Airport in 1999.
John Kerry

Senator John Kerry made a campaign stop at the Local 479 International Fire Fighters Union Hall, speaking to voters about mostly domestic policy, and shaking hands, during his run for U.S. President in 2003.
Dick Cheney

Vice President Dick Cheney waves to a crowd of supporters during a campaign rally at Pima County Fairgrounds on July 31, 2004.
George W. Bush

President George W. Bush has a laugh with Arizona Senator John McCain during a town hall session held at the Tucson Convention Center on March 21, 2005. After a failed run for President in 2000, McCain threw his support to Bush. Bush returned the favor in 2008, when Sen. McCain run against Barack Obama.
Barack and Michelle Obama

First Lady Michelle Obama walks along the tarmac with Haile Thomas , left, and James Ianni at Tucson International Airport on April 30, 2012. Mrs. Obama was in Tucson for a campaign fundraiser for incumbent Pres. Barack Obama.
Bernie Sanders

Democratic candidate for president Bernie Sanders drives home a point at his rally at the Reid Park DeMeester Outdoor Performance Center in 2015.
Donald Trump rally in Tucson

Donald Trump speaks to the crowd during the Republican presidential candidate's rally at the Tucson Convention Center in March, 2016. The rally was marred by some yelling and clashes with protesters.
Tucson Pence Visit

Vice President Mike Pence fist pumps while giving remarks at a "Make America Great Again Victory" rally at the Tucson Jet Center, on Oct. 30, 2020.
Donald Trump "Make America Great Again" Campaign Rally

President Donald Trump dances to the "Y.M.C.A" after speaking during a campaign rally at Tucson Jet Center, 6720 S. Plumber Ave., in Tucson, Ariz., on October 19, 2020.
Kamala Harris

Democratic vice presidential candidate Kamala Harris speaks to a crowd during a drive-in campaign rally at Pima Community College West in Tucson, Ariz. on October 28, 2020. Harris visited Tucson and Phoenix in a last push to get out the vote six days before Election Day.
To contact opinion columnist Tim Steller: tsteller@tucson.com or 807-7789. On Twitter: @senyorreporter.