ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV

Skip to main contentSkip to main content
Register for more free articles.
Back to homepage
Keep reading with a digital access subscription.
You are the owner of this collection.
Edit Collection
You have permission to edit this collection.
Edit
ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
70°
  • News
    • Sign up for newsletters
    • Local
    • Arizona
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Nation & World
    • Markets & Stocks
    • SaddleBrooke
    • Politics
    • Archives
    • News Tip
  • ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
    • ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
    • ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV-Tutorial
    • Archives
    • Merchandise
    • Public Notices
  • Obituaries
    • Recent Obituaries
    • Find an Obituary
  • Opinion
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Opinion & Editorials
    • National Columnists
  • Sports
    • Arizona Wildcats
    • Greg Hansen
    • High Schools
    • Roadrunners
  • Lifestyles
    • Events Calendar
    • Arts & Theatre
    • Food & Cooking
    • Movies & TV
    • Movie Listings
    • Music
    • Comics
    • Games
    • Columns
    • Play
    • Home & Gardening
    • Health
    • Get Healthy
    • Parenting
    • Fashion
    • People
    • Pets
    • Travel
    • Faith
    • Retro Tucson
    • History
    • Travel
    • Outdoors & Rec
  • Brand Ave. Studios
  • Join the community
    • News tip
  • Buy & Sell
    • Place an Ad
    • Shop Local
    • Jobs
    • Freedom RV AZ
    • Marketplace
    • I Love A Deal
  • Shopping
  • Customer Service
    • Manage My Account
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
    • Contact us
  • Mobile Apps
  • Weather: Live Radar
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
© 2026 Lee Enterprises
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy
ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
News+
Read Today's ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
News+
  • News
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion
  • Wildcats
  • Lifestyles
  • Newsletters
  • Comics & Puzzles
  • Jobs
  • Freedom RV AZ
  • 70° Clear
Share This
  • SMS
  • Email
How do Sumlin, Tate rate? Ranking the Pac-12 coach-quarterback combinations
Share this
  • SMS
  • Email
  • Print
Editor's Pick

How do Sumlin, Tate rate? Ranking the Pac-12 coach-quarterback combinations

  • Michael Lev
  • Aug 25, 2018
  • Aug 25, 2018 Updated Aug 31, 2018

Editor's note: This story is part of the ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV's 2018 college football preview.Ìý

Who's the leader of the Pac?

Pac 12 Championship Football

Southern California players and coaches celebrate after beating Stanford in the 2017 Pac-12 championship game in Santa Clara, California.

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP Photo

Who has the best head coach-quarterback combination in the Pac-12? Who has the worst? Where do the Arizona Wildcats fit in?

We answer all those questions with our HC-QB Combo Rankings. We ranked the coaches 1-12, as well as the quarterbacks (or in some cases, quarterback situations). First place was worth 12 points, second place 11, etc. We then added it all up. Here’s how it came out (rankings within each category in parentheses; ties broken by higher ranking in coach category):

No. 1 Washington

Washington Jake Browning

Washington quarterback Jake Browning

Jae C. Hong / AP Photo

Coach:ÌýChris Petersen (1)

Quarterback(s):ÌýJake Browning (2)

Comment:ÌýPeterson won big at Boise State, and he’s winning big at Washington, including back-to-back seasons with double-figure victories and the conference’s lone College Football Playoff berth over the past three years. No Pac-12 passer has more experience than Browning, who has compiled a 78-24 TD-INT ratio, a 64.4 percent completion rate and a 153.3 rating in his three years as a starter.

No. 2: Stanford

Alamo Bowl Football

Stanford quarterback K.J. CostelloÌý

Austin Gay / AP Photo

Coach: David Shaw (2)

Quarterback(s):ÌýK.J. Costello (5)

Comment: Shaw took the baton from Jim Harbaugh and hasn’t stopped running, winning 10 or more games in five of seven seasons at the school with the most stringent academic standards in the Pac-12. Costello showed great promise in his first year as the starter, fashioning a 14-4 TD-INT ratio, but still must prove he can do it over the long haul.

No. 3: Arizona

University of Arizona vs Northern Arizona

Arizona quarterback Khalil Tate (14) slices through the Northern Arizona defense in the third quarter of their game Sept. 2, 2017.

Kelly Presnell / ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV

Coach: Kevin Sumlin (6)

Quarterback(s):ÌýKhalil Tate (1)

Comment: Sumlin won 67.3 percent of his games at Houston and 66.2 percent at Texas A&M; either would rank as the highest mark at Arizona for any coach over the past 40 years. Tate doesn’t have the experience of Browning or the NFL measurables of Oregon’s Justin Herbert, but if you were drafting Pac-12 quarterbacks for the 2018 season, is there anyone you’d rather have?

No. 4: Utah

Coach: Kyle Whittingham (4)

Quarterback(s):ÌýTyler Huntley (7)

Comment: Those who didn’t think Utah could win consistently in the Pac-12 underestimated Whittingham, who has led the Utes to four straight bowl appearances and a 35-17 record over that span. Huntley can run (537 yards, six TDs), completed a high percentage of his passes a year ago (63.8) but needs to cut down on turnovers (15-10 TD-INT).

No. 5: Oregon

Coach: Mario Cristobal (9)

Quarterback(s): Justin Herbert (3)

Comment: This isn’t Cristobal’s first rodeo; he led a moribund Florida International program – which went 0-12 prior to his arrival – to winning seasons in Years 4 and 5. Herbert has star potential and the eyes of the NFL upon him; he just needs to prove he can stay healthy and produce for a full season after missing five-plus games last year.

No. 6: UCLA

Coach: Chip Kelly (3)

Quarterback(s): Wilton Speight/Dorian Thompson-Robinson/Devon Modster (10)

Comment: If we were doing this in 2012, Kelly would rank No. 1; he went 46-7 in his four seasons at Oregon but drops a couple of notches over concerns about whether he can approach that success now that many have co-opted his methods and schemes. Speight completed 61.6 percent of his passes with an 18-7 TD-INT ratio at Michigan in 2016; Thompson-Robinson fits Kelly’s system better and is the quarterback of the future, if not the present.

No. 7: Colorado

Texas St Colorado Football

Colorado quarterback Steven Montez

David Zalubowski / The Associated Press

Coach: Mike MacIntyre (8)

Quarterback(s): Steven Montez (6)

Comment: MacIntyre led the Buffaloes to the Pac-12 Championship game in 2016, but that’s their only winning season on his watch, and he could be in trouble if they don’t make a bowl game in ’18. Colorado’s success hinges largely on Montez, a redshirt junior with NFL tools and measurables who must become more consistent after an up-and-down ’17 campaign.

No. 8: Arizona State

Coach: Herm Edwards (11)

Quarterback(s): Manny Wilkins (4)

Comment: Even Edwards’ most ardent supporters can’t dispute these facts: He was a sub-.500 head coach in the NFL (54-74) and hasn’t coached in college since 1989, when he was the defensive backs coach at San Jose State. Wilkins is probably the most underrated QB in the Pac-12; he completed 63.4 percent of his passes and accounted for 27 touchdowns last season while leading ASU to the Sun Bowl.

No. 9: Washington State

Washington St Football

Washington State coach Mike Leach

Ted S. Warren / AP Photo

Coach: Mike Leach (5)

Quarterback(s):ÌýGardner Minshew/Trey Tinsley (11)

Comment: Leach posted 10 straight winning seasons at Texas Tech; his overall winning percentage at WSU — maybe the hardest place to recruit to in the Pac-12 — is just .500, but the Cougars are 26-13 over the past three seasons. Leach’s quarterbacks always put up prolific numbers; if grad transfer Minshew wins the job, he could surpass the stats he totaled in two seasons at East Carolina (3,487 yards, 24 TD passes).

No. 10: USC

USC Replacing Darnold Football

USC quarterback Jack Sears

Jae C. Hong / AP Photo

Coach: Clay Helton (7)

Quarterback(s): JT Daniels/Jack Sears (9)

Comment: Helton has gone 21-6 in his two full seasons as USC’s coach, including a Rose Bowl win and a Pac-12 championship, yet a segment of USC’s hard-to-please fan base still isn’t sure he’s the right man for the job. Daniels might be the next great Trojans QB, but it’s hard to rank a true freshman ahead of any established veteran, no matter how high Daniels’ upside might be.

No. 11: Cal

Arizona-California Football

California quarterback Ross Bowers

Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP Photo

Coach: Justin Wilcox (10)

Quarterback(s): Ross Bowers (8)

Comment: Wilcox got off to a promising start, going 5-7 with wins over North Carolina, Ole Miss and Washington State, but must prove himself over the long haul at a place that lacks the infrastructure of many of its Pac-12 rivals. Bowers needs to build off his finish to 2017; he had only four interceptions in his final eight games after throwing eight in his first four.

No. 12: Oregon State

Oregon St Smith Football (copy)

Oregon State coach Jonathan Smith

Andy Cripe / AP Photo

Coach: Jonathan Smith (12)

Quarterback(s): Jake Luton/Jack Colletto/Conor Blount (12)

Comment: This is the first head-coaching job for Smith, who returned to Corvallis (where he played quarterback) after a successful four-year run as the offensive coordinator/QB coach at Washington. That once-touted JC transfer Luton didn’t quickly pull away from the competition in spring or training camp probably isn’t a good sign for the downtrodden Beavers.

Michael Lev

Michael Lev

Sports Reporter/Columnist

  • Author email

Related to this collection

Breaking down Khalil Tate’s 9 interceptions from 2017: What can we learn?

Breaking down Khalil Tate’s 9 interceptions from 2017: What can we learn?

Analyzing the Arizona quarterback's interceptions reveals a pattern: He gets in trouble when he tries to do too much.Ìý

Greg Hansen's guide to the 2018 college football season

Greg Hansen's guide to the 2018 college football season

Star columnist Greg Hansen provides an inside look at college football in 2018.

Greg Hansen: Perfect timing could lead first-year coach Kevin Sumlin, Cats to big things

Greg Hansen: Perfect timing could lead first-year coach Kevin Sumlin, Cats to big things

Arizona lands big-name coach with history of success in his first season. Kevin Sumlin, you're up.Ìý

With stars and flaws, can 2018 Wildcats live up to lofty expectations?

With stars and flaws, can 2018 Wildcats live up to lofty expectations?

An in-depth look at the UA’s offense, defense and special teams.

Dynamic between Kevin Sumlin, Khalil Tate will determine Arizona Wildcats’ 2018 fate

Dynamic between Kevin Sumlin, Khalil Tate will determine Arizona Wildcats’ 2018 fate

The coach and the QB must have a productive working relationship for the Cats to succeed; Sumlin’s history suggests they will.

Here's a week-by-week look at Arizona's 2018 football schedule

Here's a week-by-week look at Arizona's 2018 football schedule

Editor's note: This story is part of the ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV's 2018 college football preview.Ìý

Michael Lev's preseason poll: Clemson, Alabama remain the class of college football

Michael Lev's preseason poll: Clemson, Alabama remain the class of college football

Editor's note: This story runs in the ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV's 2018 college football preview, which is available Sunday.

Thanks to Khalil Tate, other QBs, future of the Pac-12 is up in the air

Thanks to Khalil Tate, other QBs, future of the Pac-12 is up in the air

Editor's note: This story appears in the Star's 2018 college football preview.

Only time will tell if ASU's Herm Edwards experience pays off

Only time will tell if ASU's Herm Edwards experience pays off

The Devils return a standout quarterback and a few stellar defenders, but questions about their coach — and plan — remain.Ìý

Former Wildcat Antonio Pierce eager to mold future football stars … at ASU

Former Wildcat Antonio Pierce eager to mold future football stars … at ASU

Longtime NFL player, football analyst joined former ESPN colleague Herm Edwards at ASU in December.

Talking Tate: What the rest of the Pac-12 is saying about Arizona’s playmaking QB

Talking Tate: What the rest of the Pac-12 is saying about Arizona’s playmaking QB

Editor's note: This story is part of the ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV's 2018 college football preview.

From Larry Smith and Dick Tomey to Kevin Sumlin, Cats coaches have been front-page news

From Larry Smith and Dick Tomey to Kevin Sumlin, Cats coaches have been front-page news

Editor's note: This story is part of the ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV's 2018 college football preview.

ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • YouTube
  • This is Tucson
  • Saddlebag Notes

Sites & Partners

  • ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV
  • Events calendar
  • Online Features
  • Get Healthy

Services

  • Contact us
  • RSS feeds
  • Newsletters
  • Photo reprints
  • Subscription FAQ
  • Licensing
  • Shopping
© Copyright 2026 ÃÛÌÒÓ°ÏñAV, PO Box 26887 Tucson, AZ 85726-6887
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | | Do Not Sell My Info | Cookie Preferences
Powered by from .
  • Notifications
  • Settings
You don't have any notifications.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News